Verdict · Updated April 2026
Citi Custom Cash Card for First Credit Card
The Citi Custom Cash Card is workable for first credit card but not the strongest fit — ranked #24 of 47 eligible cards. Several cards listed in alternatives outperform it for this specific use case.
Rank #24 of 4750th percentileWorkable but not optimal
Reviewed by CardCompare Editorial Board
|Data-driven ranking|Updated April 2026
Citi Custom Cash Card
Citi · No annual fee
A unique cashback card that automatically identifies your top eligible spend category each billing cycle and gives you 5% back on up to $500 in that category. Categories include restaurants, gas, grocery, select travel, transit, streaming, drugstores, home improvement, fitness, and live entertainment.
Full card review
Earn math — First Credit Card profile
Based on typical first credit card spending of $9,720/year across the categories below.
Annual rewards
$97
Annual fee
$0
Net value
$97
Easy approvalZero feeSimple rewardsReports to all 3 bureaus
Where the Citi Custom Cash Card wins for first credit card
- Zero annual fee — no fixed cost to worry about
- Simple reward structure — easy to maximize without category tracking
Where it falls short
- Typically requires good credit — may deny thin-file applicants
Top 3 alternatives for first credit card
Cards that rank higher than or close to the Citi Custom Cash Card on our first credit card scoring model.
How the Citi Custom Cash Card performs for other use cases
Frequently asked questions
Is the Citi Custom Cash Card a good card for first credit card?⌄
The Citi Custom Cash Card is workable for first credit card but not the strongest fit — ranked #24 of 47 eligible cards. Several cards listed in alternatives outperform it for this specific use case.
How much can I earn with the Citi Custom Cash Card on first credit card spending?⌄
At the typical first credit card spending profile of $9,720/year, this card earns approximately $97 in rewards — net $97 after the $0 annual fee.
What are better alternatives to the Citi Custom Cash Card for first credit card?⌄
Our top 3 alternatives are Chase Freedom Rise, Bank of America Travel Rewards for Students, Discover it Student Cash Back. Each ranks higher on our use-case scoring model for first credit card.
What credit score do I need for the Citi Custom Cash Card?⌄
The Citi Custom Cash Card typically requires good credit. Approval also depends on income, existing debt, and application history — a score in the stated range doesn't guarantee approval.
Is the Citi Custom Cash Card's annual fee worth it for this use case?⌄
The Citi Custom Cash Card has no annual fee — there's no breakeven to clear, so any rewards earned on first credit card spending are pure profit.
Want the full card review?
See rewards, fees, and all perks of the Citi Custom Cash Card